Lymm 26 – 30 Cinderford
1st Team Match Report | Saturday November 14 2026
Lymm pay for missed opportunities
On a beautiful, sunny but breezy autumnal day at Beechwood, Lymm faced Gloucestershire-based Cinderford, for the third time in this league. Having beaten league-leaders Redruth last week Cinderford were always going to be a difficult opponent and so it proved.
Lymm started brightly enough with ball-in-hand but could not finish adequately. It was to be the tale of the afternoon. Back rower Fin Williams was held up over the line as Lymm continued to press but no cigar.
Cinderford broke out and worked their way down the field but also could not score from 5m out. Whilst defending stoically Lymm gave away a tackle penalty under the posts which the visitors converted. 0 – 3 after 10 mins and against the run of play. This opportunism for taking points when available also became something of a theme but more of that later.
Lymm’s collective chin remained up and, with a penalty in front of the post, Lymm chose a scrum. An interesting selection which nearly paid off but a double movement on the tryline meant Lymm were denied again.
Following two more attacking scrums in good positions in the visitor’s 22, a penalty was awarded to Lymm which was taken quickly and gave Lymm’s outstanding back row Rhys Lilly the chance to score to the left of the posts, which Shard converted. 7 – 3 after 20 mins.
Lymm’s tail appeared to be well up at this point as they went through there attacking shapes. A line out 15m from Cinderford’s line looked to be an ideal opportunity but the throw was deemed not straight. The subsequent scrum saw Lymm heaved mightily backwards and the opportunity slipped away.
Lymm threatened once more but mistakes began to creep in, with a chip through going too far and a kick to touch being missed. Lymm’s build-up play was exciting and a sight to behold as the ball was swiftly moved one way across the field, then the other, but penetration was proving illusive. The defensive effort by Cinderford at this point was clearly, as it turned out, match-winning.
As Lymm pressed, there was a questionable refereeing decision made in the visitor’s 22. The defender went into the maul from the side, picked up the ball and fed his left winger who ran 75m to score under the posts. 7 – 10 as the half came to a close and Cinderford were in front once again, much to the chagrin of the home support.
Half time: Lymm 7 – 10 Cinderford
Early in the second half Cinderford were awarded a line out following a well-taken 50 – 22 kick to touch. Following the ubiquitous rolling maul the ball was moved wide where the back row forward broke through to score under the posts. 7 – 17 after 35 mins. Two killer tries either side of half time were proving hard to take by the Lymm faithful.
To compound the issue, Lymm’s star open side Josh Hadland also left the field with an injured shoulder. Despite facing an increased wind in their faces Lymm were once again held up over the line. However, an attacking line out gave hooker James Pitcher the chance to score wide out on the left for an unconverted try. 12 – 17 on 51 mins.
Cinderford then won another penalty in front of the posts which they duly took 2 minutes later. 12 – 20 and two scores in front. Despite once again Cinderford’s stoic defence, Lymm centre Jack Reynolds, with his twinkle toes, broached the defensive line and scored to the right of the posts. 19 – 20 with the conversion, on 65 mins, and game on!
A further penalty by Cinderford in front of the posts was also converted. 19 – 23 with 10 minutes remaining. Then the moment all the fast and slick hands had been building up to as Rhys Lilley scored a well taken second try for the lead which Shard converted. 26 – 23 and Lymm’s noses were in front at last, with a bonus try to boot!
Then came the coup de artificial gras! An attacking line out following a penalty for not releasing gave Cinderford the one opportunity they had been looking for. The rolling maul was halted so the ball was thrown wide and long to the left winger who dived over in the corner, for a spectacular match-winning try. Even the conversion from wide out went over! 26 – 30 with minutes left on the clock.
Despite a sustained attack including huge surge from Lymm’s pack, which pushed Cinderford’s pack off the ball from their own scrum put-in, Lymm just could not get the score they cherished and the whistle went for full time.
Full time: Lymm 26 – 30 Cinderford
It was a case of taking the few scoring opportunities that Cinderford created, combined with an almighty defensive effort to repel Lymm’s attacking flair time and again. This was all hard to take in some respects for the home supporters, especially when some key decisions went against the hosts but that is the game we play. On another day…….
Andy Davies was disappointed but pragmatic in his summary:
“I thought it was a terrific game with both teams having spells of pressure and territory. We probably didn’t capitalise on our spell in the first half enough and left some points out there.
‘It’s been a fantastic day at the club with four teams playing at home with our very old defence coach,Tom Bray, playing for the Reapers (vets) as a curtain-raiser. Big congratulations to Toby Phillips and the 2nd team who bounced back with a win today against old rivals Macclesfield, and played some great rugby,” he concluded.
Lymm First XV: 1.Ben Lilley (53). 2. James Pitcher (123) *C 3. Matty Hand (145)* 4. Nathan Ovien (5). Sam Dickenson (22)* 6. Fin Williams (11)* 7. Josh Hadland (85)* 8. Rhys Lilley (104)* 9. Tom Manaton (58) 10. Tom Shard (176)* 11. Joe Heaton (30)* 12. Jack Reynolds (60) 13. James Hampson (9) 14. Will Hitchen (6) 15. Alex Muckerjee (11)*
Finishers: 16. Logan Byrne (9) 17. Joe Higgins (48)* 18. Max Ure (21)* 19. Jamie Cope (8)* 20. Cal Morris (90).
() No of Lymm 1st XV League appearances
*Product of Lymm M&J’s/Colts Academy
Referee: Peter Connor
Assistant Referees: D Jon Petzing and martin Sly
4th Official: Malcolm Kimber
Match Report: Simon Plumb